On a consideration of the facts that the enemy was operating in country
well known to him, that he had an Air Service and Camel Corps when the
Union had not, that he had carefully interned all enemy and suspicious
subjects, and that in the union he had sympathy that went to the extent
of armed rebellion, it will perhaps be readily conceded that he had a
great advantage on the matter of procuring information. It is not of
much interest to investigate the extent to which he had availed himself
of these advantages, but it is instructive from a point of future
application, to note some inconceivable oversights of the enemy that
enabled the Union General Staff to obtain their information. There was
no - or a very perfunctory - internal censorship over newspapers,
letters, telegrams and wireless messages, these almost invariably
disclosed dispositions or intended movements, especially wireless
messages were a never failing source of information. When a wireless
station had for days been ordering so many kilos of butter for the
Fourth Battery, cut grass for the Third Company, boot laces for another
company, and so on, it was in a few days possible not only to have a
complete marching state of the troops to whom the wireless station was
attached but also to have considerable information on the interior
economy of the units and the character - or want of it - of the
Officers. If then certain things were urgently ordered to be delivered
by a certain date, a move by the units concerned could with probability
be speculated on, generally in a direction and to a destination that
could be anticipated from the indiscretions of the previous messages.
When eventually the official marching orders in cypher were transmitted
from Headquarters the telegram only served to enable the cypher keyword
for that period to be discovered by the the Union Staff, as a very
close guess of the contents of the message could be made and the enemy
were obliging enough frequently to give part of a message in cypher
only and the rest in clear. Reconnaissance by aeroplane was to the
Northern Force only available after the occupation of Karibib, while
the Central, Southern and Eastern Forces never had the benefit of air
information. The enemy however almost daily photographed and bombed the
dispositions of the Central Force and also made air reconnaissances
over the Northern dispositions. Another point of interest in the
intelligence work of this campaign that must be noted for future
guidance was the futility on depending on persons with alleged local
knowledge of the country. Of the numerous guides engaged, it was with
few exceptions found that they invariably had complete knowledge of the
entire country except just that particular portion on which information
or column guiding was immediately required. The best of these guides
went entirely wrong when leading a column in the first advance from
Swakop to Goanikonas, fortunately the Brigade Major had checked the
line of march by prismatic compass and when he discovered how far they
were deviating from the objective he took over the guiding and marched
by compass, with the result however that valuable time had been lost
and the column arrived so late that the enemy could not be intercepted.
The left wing of the 2nd Brigade also went wrong on the night march to
Jackhalswater through trusting entirely to guides with local knowledge,
and it is known that one German column in the attack on Trekkopies
never reached its objective for the same reason, although they had a
much better knowledge of the country. It therefore appears safe to
assume that reliance should in these cases be placed more on
mathematical direction.